As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.
The Pendleton controversy centers on cultural appropriation, product naming, and who benefits from Native-inspired blanket designs. For a separate product-selection guide, compare Best Blankets and Throws for Beds, Sofas, and Layering by material, warmth, size, and intended use. Pendleton Woolen Mills is not a Native-owned company, but it has built a large part of its blanket identity around patterns associated with Indigenous peoples.
Critics argue that the company has earned money from Native names, stories, and design traditions without always giving clear credit, permission, or direct financial benefit to the communities connected to them. The guide to What Is So Special About Pendleton Blankets? covers their separate material, design, and brand-history appeal. Others point out that Pendleton blankets have also become meaningful gifts and ceremonial items in many Native communities, so the relationship is more complex than a simple boycott question.
Why Pendleton Blankets Are Connected to Native Communities
Pendleton began producing wool trade blankets for Native customers in the late 1800s. The company developed colorful geometric patterns after studying the styles, color choices, and preferences of tribes in the Pacific Northwest and Southwest.
Over time, the blankets became widely used in Native communities. They may be given for graduations, weddings, births, memorials, naming ceremonies, powwows, and other important events. Some families keep them as heirlooms or turn worn blankets into pillows, clothing, and keepsakes.
This long history is one reason people have different views about the brand. A Pendleton blanket may be a valued cultural gift to one person while representing commercial appropriation to another.
The Main Cultural Appropriation Concern
Pendleton is a non-Native company. The Blanket Buying Guide explains how to assess material, warmth, size, construction, and intended use without treating a brand name as proof of quality. Many of Pendleton's best-known blankets use geometric designs, tribal references, and stories connected to Native cultures.
Critics say the company helped create a broad “Southwestern” or “Native-inspired” look that mixes traditions from many different tribes. That can remove designs from their original nations, meanings, and artists. There are hundreds of distinct tribes in the United States, each with its own history and visual traditions. Treating all Native design as one general style can hide those differences.
The concern is not simply that Pendleton sells geometric blankets. Geometric shapes are used in many cultures. The harder questions are:
- Was a design copied from a specific artist or tradition?
- Was permission given?
- Is the correct tribe named?
- Is the artist clearly credited?
- Does the artist or community receive compensation?
- Could shoppers mistakenly think the product was Native-made?
These details matter because “Native-inspired” and “Native-made” do not mean the same thing.
What Happened With the Sioux Star Blanket?
A major part of the controversy involves a blanket once called the Sioux Star Blanket.
In 2013, federal officials raised concerns that Pendleton’s online marketing could imply that the blanket was made by Native Sioux quilters. The Indian Arts and Crafts Act prohibits falsely marketing products as Native American-made when they are not.
Pendleton changed the blanket’s name to Plains Star Blanket. It also changed a website category from “Native American” to “Native American Inspired” and agreed to provide $41,250 to the Red Cloud Indian Heritage Center in Pine Ridge.
The issue was not that a non-Native company could never sell a star-patterned blanket. The concern was that the name and marketing might lead shoppers to misunderstand who made the product.
Does Pendleton Work With Native Artists Now?
Pendleton currently sells some blankets designed in partnership with named Native artists. The company says these artists are credited and compensated for their work. It also partners with the American Indian College Fund on blankets designed by Native artists and tribal college students. A portion of proceeds from that collection supports the organization’s scholarship work.
These programs address some of the criticism by putting artist names, personal stories, and tribal identities on product pages.
However, artist collaborations do not automatically resolve concerns about every older or in-house Pendleton pattern. Shoppers may still want to check each product separately rather than assuming every Native-inspired blanket was designed or approved by a Native artist.
Why Some Native People Still Value Pendleton Blankets
It is important not to treat Native opinions as a single viewpoint.
Pendleton blankets have been exchanged and used in Native communities for generations. In some families, the blankets carry meaning because of how they are gifted and used, even though the manufacturer is not Native-owned.
A blanket given by an elder, presented at a graduation, or used during a ceremony may have deep personal importance. That meaning comes from the people and occasion, not only from the company that wove the fabric.
The Pendleton controversy centers on cultural appropriation, product naming, and who benefits from Native-inspired blanket designs; learn how often blankets should be washed based on use, pets, illness, allergies, fabric, layering, care labels, and how quickly soil or odor builds up.
For this reason, some Native people continue to buy, give, collect, sew with, and wear Pendleton wool. Others prefer to support Native-owned companies or individual Native weavers. Both views can exist at the same time.
Is It Wrong to Own a Pendleton Blanket?
Owning a Pendleton blanket is not automatically disrespectful. Context matters.
A simple wool blanket used on a bed, sofa, guest bed, or RV bed is different from claiming that it is an authentic handwoven Native textile. The main problem occurs when people misrepresent the item, use sacred meanings carelessly, or assume every geometric design belongs to one general Native culture.
When discussing the blanket, describe it accurately:
- Say it was made by Pendleton.
- Do not call it Native-made unless the product listing confirms that.
- Mention the named artist when there is one.
- Do not invent a tribal meaning for a pattern.
- Avoid calling every geometric blanket “Navajo,” “Indian,” or “tribal.”
An older Pendleton blanket can also be kept as a family heirloom without ignoring the company’s complicated history.
How to Shop for a Blanket More Thoughtfully
Start by reading the current product listing. Look beyond broad phrases such as “inspired by the American West.”
Check who designed it
A good listing should name the artist when the blanket is based on a specific person’s work. The guide to What Are High Quality Blankets? provides separate construction and material checks for evaluating the physical product. Look for the artist’s nation or community, biography, and explanation of the design.
Check who owns the company
“Native-designed” and “Native-owned” are different. A non-Native company may commission a Native artist, while a Native-owned company keeps more of the business within Indigenous communities.
Neither label should be guessed from the appearance of the pattern.
Check how the artist benefits
Look for clear language about compensation, licensing, scholarships, donations, or proceeds. General phrases such as “honoring Native culture” do not explain where the money goes.
The exact agreement may not be public, so avoid assuming that a partnership includes royalties or permanent design ownership unless the current listing or artist states that it does.
Consider Native-owned alternatives
Native-owned blanket companies and independent artists offer another option. Some use licensed artwork and identify the individual artist and nation behind each design.
Buying directly from an artist can provide a clearer connection between the maker, the story, and the product. It may also give you a blanket with a more specific cultural meaning instead of a general Southwest-style pattern.
Choose based on practical bedding needs too
Ethical questions matter, but the blanket still needs to work in your room.
Before buying, check:
- Blanket dimensions
- Fiber content
- Bed size
- Weight and warmth
- Whether the fabric feels smooth or fuzzy
- Whether it needs dry cleaning
- Whether your washer is large enough
- Whether pet hair will be easy to remove
Many Pendleton wool blankets require dry cleaning rather than a normal laundry cycle. Always follow the current care label. Wool can shrink, felt, or change texture when washed or dried with the wrong method.
For a child’s bed, dorm room, pet-friendly home, or frequently washed guest bed, an easier-care blanket may be more practical.
The Bottom Line
The Pendleton controversy is mainly about a non-Native company using Native-associated designs, names, and stories while selling mass-produced blankets.
The debate includes a documented marketing dispute involving the former Sioux Star Blanket, broader concerns about cultural appropriation, and questions about credit and financial benefit. At the same time, Pendleton blankets have a long and meaningful place in many Native families and ceremonies.
There is no single opinion shared by every Native person. A thoughtful shopper should check who designed a blanket, how it is described, where the money goes, and whether a Native-owned or artist-led option better matches their values.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Pendleton Native American-owned?
No. Pendleton Woolen Mills is not a Native-owned company. It is a family-owned American textile company. Some of its blankets are created with Native artists, but that does not make the entire company Native-owned.
Did Pendleton steal Native American designs?
Critics accuse Pendleton of profiting from Native-associated designs and combining cultural traditions without enough permission, credit, or community benefit. Not every Pendleton pattern is a direct copy of a specific Native artwork, so each design should be considered separately.
What was the Sioux Star Blanket controversy?
Federal officials raised concerns that the product’s name and marketing could imply it was made by Native Sioux quilters. Pendleton renamed it the Plains Star Blanket, changed its website wording, and provided money to the Red Cloud Indian Heritage Center.
Are Pendleton blankets actually made by Native Americans?
Most Pendleton blankets are manufactured by Pendleton, not handwoven by Native artisans. Some designs are created by named Native artists. Check the current product page for the designer and manufacturing details.
Is it cultural appropriation to use a Pendleton blanket?
Using one as an ordinary blanket is not automatically cultural appropriation. Problems are more likely when someone falsely calls it Native-made, invents cultural meanings, or uses culturally important imagery without respect or understanding.
Are there Native-owned alternatives to Pendleton?
Yes. Native-owned blanket companies and independent Native artists sell blankets featuring licensed or artist-created designs. Look for clear information about ownership, artist credit, tribal identity, and compensation.
Can a Pendleton wool blanket go in a washing machine?
It depends on the specific blanket. Many Pendleton wool blankets list dry cleaning as the recommended care method. Check the sewn-in care label before washing, drying, bleaching, ironing, or using heat.
Can You Dry Clean Pendleton? Compare five bed blankets by material, warmth, weight, size, wash care, and shedding risk to find a practical layer for your bedroom and climate. Learn how to wash throw blankets by checking fiber, care labels, stains, load size, detergent, washer settings, drying method, and shrinkage risk.
