As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.
Mattress protectors can help keep a mattress cleaner, but they also have downsides. Some trap heat, make noise, shift under the fitted sheet, or change how the mattress feels. Waterproof models can be harder to wash and may wear out faster if they are dried with too much heat.
The best choice depends on why you need one. A child’s bed, dorm bed, guest room, RV bed, and hot sleeper’s bed may all need different types of protection.
Common Disadvantages of Mattress Protectors
They Can Make the Bed Feel Warmer
Waterproof mattress protectors often include a thin backing that blocks liquid. This layer may also reduce airflow.
A warmer protector can be uncomfortable for:
- Hot sleepers
- People who share a bed
- Bedrooms without strong air conditioning
- Thick foam mattresses that already hold warmth
- Warm dorm rooms or RV bedrooms
Some protectors use thinner fabrics or breathable designs, but no waterproof layer will feel exactly like sleeping without one.
Look at the current product listing for information about the fabric, waterproof backing, and cooling claims. Keep in mind that words such as “breathable” do not guarantee that a protector will feel cool to every sleeper.
Some Make Crinkling or Rustling Sounds
A low-quality or stiff waterproof protector may make noise when you roll over. The sound can be more noticeable on a quiet night or when two people share the bed.
Noise is often caused by:
- A thick waterproof backing
- Loose material under the sheet
- A protector that is too large
- A fitted skirt that does not hold tightly
- Fabric that has become stiff after washing
A soft fitted sheet and a properly sized protector may reduce the sound. However, they may not remove it completely.
They Can Change the Feel of the Mattress
A mattress protector adds another layer between you and the mattress. Even a thin layer can slightly change how the surface feels.
A padded protector may make a firm mattress feel softer. A tight waterproof protector may make a soft mattress feel less flexible. Thick quilting can also reduce the close-fitting feel of foam or a pillow top.
This matters most when you already like the exact feel of your mattress.
A mattress protector should not be confused with a mattress pad or topper. A protector is mainly made to guard the mattress. A mattress pad adds light cushioning, while a topper is a thicker comfort layer.
Poorly Fitted Protectors Can Shift or Bunch
A protector that does not fit well may slide, wrinkle, or pull away from the corners. This can create lumps under the fitted sheet.
Fit problems are common when:
- The mattress is unusually thin
- The mattress is very deep
- A topper has been added
- The bed has rounded RV corners
- The protector has a weak elastic skirt
- The wrong mattress size was ordered
Measure the mattress before buying. Check its width, length, and total height. Include any topper in the height measurement.
“Pocket depth” means the tallest mattress thickness that the fitted sides are designed to cover. A protector with pockets that are too shallow may pop off. One with very deep pockets may feel loose on a thin mattress.
Waterproof Layers Can Wear Out
The waterproof part of a protector may weaken over time. Heat, harsh washing products, stretching, and repeated use can affect the backing.
Possible signs of wear include:
- Peeling or cracking
- Small holes
- Stiff areas
- Separation between layers
- Liquid passing through
- A protector that no longer lies flat
A protector may still look clean even when its waterproof layer is damaged. Follow the care label, especially before using hot water, bleach, fabric softener, or high dryer heat.
Washing Can Be Inconvenient
Mattress protectors are larger and heavier than many fitted sheets. Waterproof protectors may also hold water during the wash cycle.
This can cause problems in:
- Compact washing machines
- Portable washers
- Shared dorm laundry rooms
- Small RV washers
- Machines with limited drum space
A bulky protector needs room to move during washing. Packing it tightly into a small washer may lead to poor cleaning or an uneven spin cycle.
Some protectors also take longer to dry. High heat may damage certain waterproof layers, so the care label may call for low heat or air drying.
This can make laundry day harder when you need to remake the bed quickly.
They May Not Dry Evenly
The waterproof backing can trap pockets of water. A protector may feel dry on the fabric side but still be damp in folds or around the elastic edges.
Putting it back on the bed while damp can create an unpleasant feel and smell. Spread it out fully after washing and check the corners before using it again.
A drying rack may help, but large protectors can take up a lot of space. Make sure the protector is supported so the wet weight does not stretch the elastic.
Some Are Difficult to Put On
Fitted protectors go on much like fitted sheets, but tight elastic can make the job harder. This is especially true with:
- Heavy mattresses
- Beds against a wall
- Bunk beds
- Deep pillow-top mattresses
- Dorm beds in tight spaces
- RV beds with limited access
Full mattress encasements are even harder to install. An encasement covers all sides of the mattress and closes with a zipper. The mattress may need to be lifted or turned so the cover can slide into place.
An encasement can offer more complete coverage, but it is less convenient to remove for regular washing.
Quilted Protectors Can Flatten
Padded or quilted protectors contain a thin fill layer. “Fill” is the material placed inside the stitched top for cushioning.
Over time, this fill may:
- Compress
- Form uneven spots
- Shift inside the quilting
- Lose some softness
- Become lumpy after washing
A quilted protector may feel comfortable at first, but it should not be expected to provide the same support or cushioning as a mattress topper.
The best choice depends on why you need one; choose a [mattress protector](/best-mattress-protectors-for-kids/) by matching it to the messes you expect, the feel you want, and the depth of your mattress.
Elastic Skirts Can Stretch Out
The fitted sides of a protector depend on elastic to stay in place. Repeated washing, pulling, and heat can weaken that elastic.
Once the skirt stretches, the protector may:
- Slip off the corners
- Move under the fitted sheet
- Hang loosely on the sides
- Create wrinkles across the bed
Check the care label before using high dryer heat. When putting the protector on, pull it evenly instead of stretching one corner as far as possible.
Some Protectors Affect Sheet Fit
A thick protector adds height to the mattress. This may make existing fitted sheets feel too tight.
This is more likely when the bed already has:
- A deep mattress
- A pillow top
- A foam topper
- An adjustable base
- Thick padded bedding layers
Measure the full mattress height after the protector and topper are in place. You may need fitted sheets with deeper pockets.
Loose sheets can also be a problem. If both the protector and fitted sheet are oversized, the layers may slide against each other.
They Can Hold Pet Hair and Lint
Some soft or quilted fabrics attract pet hair, lint, and dust. Hair can collect around the elastic skirt or stick to the top during washing.
For a pet-friendly bed, a smooth protector may be easier to clean than a plush or heavily quilted one. Shaking off loose hair before washing can also help keep it from collecting in the washer.
Check whether the protector can be machine washed often enough for your household.
Full Encasements Can Trap Air
A zipped mattress encasement may puff up or form air pockets as the mattress is placed inside. This can make installation awkward.
If the encasement is too small, the zipper and seams may be placed under extra strain. If it is too large, loose fabric may bunch under the sheets.
Choose the encasement by both mattress size and depth. Follow the manufacturer’s installation guidance rather than forcing the zipper closed.
A Protector Does Not Stop Every Type of Damage
A mattress protector has limits. Depending on its design, it may not protect against:
- Sagging
- Broken mattress parts
- Damage from an unsuitable bed frame
- Deep cuts or tears
- Large amounts of liquid left for a long time
- Wear caused by folding or bending the mattress
- Damage during moving or storage
Water-resistant and waterproof also do not mean the same thing. A water-resistant surface may slow small spills but may not fully block liquid.
Read the current product description to understand which parts are covered. Some protectors guard only the top surface, while others cover the top and sides.
Are Mattress Protectors Worth Using?
A mattress protector is often useful when spills, sweat, pet hair, or frequent guest use are likely. It can make surface cleaning easier and reduce how often the mattress itself needs attention.
However, it is not always necessary to choose the thickest or most protective model.
A simple fitted protector may suit:
- An adult bed with a low spill risk
- A guest room used only sometimes
- A hot sleeper who wants fewer layers
- A mattress that already has a washable cover
A waterproof model may be more practical for:
- Children’s beds
- Beds used by pets
- Drinks kept near the bed
- Dorm rooms
- Short-term rentals, where permitted
- Guest rooms used by many different people
A full encasement may be chosen when the owner wants coverage around the entire mattress. It takes more effort to install and remove, so it may not be the easiest option for frequent washing.
How to Reduce the Downsides
Choose the Right Type
Do not buy a thick quilted model when you only need a thin washable barrier. Extra padding may add warmth and change the mattress feel.
Choose between:
- A basic fabric protector
- A waterproof fitted protector
- A padded protector
- A full zippered encasement
Base the choice on the room, sleeper, spill risk, and laundry setup.
Measure Before Buying
Measure the mattress width, length, and height. Include any pad or topper that will stay on the bed.
This is especially important for deep mattresses, RV beds, dorm mattresses, bunk beds, and older beds with nonstandard dimensions.
Check the Care Instructions
Before washing or drying, read the care label. Waterproof materials may be damaged by treatments that ordinary cotton sheets can handle.
Check the label before using:
- Hot water
- Bleach
- Fabric softener
- Stain treatments
- High dryer heat
- An iron
Wash the protector according to the manufacturer’s current guidance.
Keep a Spare
A second protector can be useful for children’s beds, guest rooms, and pet-friendly homes. You can remake the bed while the first protector is still drying.
This is also helpful when air drying is required or when laundry access is limited.
Use Smooth Layers
Make sure the protector is pulled flat before adding the fitted sheet. Wrinkles become harder to fix once the bed is fully made.
Check each corner and smooth the center from the top of the bed toward the foot.
When a Mattress Protector May Not Be the Best Choice
You may prefer to skip a protector or choose a very thin one when:
- You are highly sensitive to extra warmth
- You dislike any change in mattress feel
- The mattress already has a removable, washable cover
- Your washer cannot safely handle bulky bedding
- The mattress has unusual dimensions
- The manufacturer advises against a certain cover type
Always check the mattress manufacturer’s guidance. Some mattresses have care or ventilation instructions that should be followed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do mattress protectors make you hot?
Some can. Waterproof backings and thick quilted layers may reduce airflow and hold more warmth. A thin protector with less padding may feel cooler, but comfort varies by sleeper and mattress type.
Do mattress protectors make noise?
Some waterproof protectors make a light crinkling or rustling sound. Noise is more likely when the backing is stiff, the fit is loose, or the protector has become damaged after washing.
Can a mattress protector change how a mattress feels?
Yes. Thick padding can make the bed feel softer, while a tight waterproof layer may reduce the flexible feel of foam or a plush mattress surface. Thin protectors usually make a smaller difference.
Why does my mattress protector keep coming off?
It may have pockets that are too shallow, stretched elastic, or the wrong dimensions. Measure the mattress height, including any topper, and compare it with the protector’s listed pocket depth.
Can mattress protectors go in the dryer?
Many can, but drying instructions vary. Waterproof layers may be damaged by high heat. Check the care label before machine drying, using heat, or choosing an air-dry setting.
How often should a mattress protector be washed?
Wash it when it is soiled and as part of your normal bedding routine. The right schedule depends on spills, pets, children, guest use, and the manufacturer’s care guidance.
Is a mattress encasement better than a fitted protector?
An encasement covers more of the mattress, but it is harder to install and remove. A fitted protector is easier to wash. The better choice depends on how much coverage you need and how often you plan to clean it.
what are the cons of waterproof mattress protectors. do you need a mattress protector. what is the most cooling mattress protector.
